Diberdayakan oleh Blogger.

Popular Posts Today

Time for Clarkson to go: Kennett

Written By Unknown on Selasa, 02 April 2013 | 16.18

Former Hawthorn president Jeff Kennett has called for coach Alastair Clarkson to be sacked at the season's end following 10th straight loss to Geelong

Keep walking, Clarko. Former Hawk president Jeff Kennett says it is time for a change at Hawthorn. Source: Herald Sun

A CONTRITE Jeff Kennett has apologised to Hawthorn coach Alastair Clarkson.

In a letter received by the Herald Sun, Kennett admitted this afternoon that his frustration prompted him to "wrongly single out Alastair for the seven point loss".

The former Hawthorn president called for Clarkson's sacking at the end of the season after Geelong scored its 10th consecutive victory over the Hawks at the MCG yesterday.

He said he sincerely apologised to Clarkson and his family "for the grief I have caused them".

Kennett's letter said:

I apologise to Alastair Clarkson.

I was out of line yesterday in holding him solely responsible for our club not saluting in the last three years and for our performance yesterday.

It is true that with out list of players and the support the club has given the football department that I felt we have underachieved over that three year period.

Of course that is a subjective view, and on each occasion we were beaten by a better team on the day.

And yes, someone must accept responsibility for those defeats.

But maybe in my support for my club I have come to expect too much!

And on reflection I was wrong to single out Alastair alone.

He, like all at the club, have done their best and Alastair has personal values which I have always gratefully respected.

We are all responsible for the good times and less successful.

Monday's game was a classic in that Hawthorn performed well in the first half and Geelong less so. But after halftime Geelong came out on a mission and turned the game on its head.

Our five goal advantage, which became three goals just before half time, quickly disappeared. We seem to have lost our mojo as Geelong found theirs.

The performance of (Paul) Chapman always has me in awe.

He is consistent in his toughness and drives the ball everytime he gets his hands on it. (Joel) Selwood is a wonderful leader who sets a very high standard of both leadership and effort.

Not to say Hawthorn was without contributors through (Sam) Mitchell, (Brad)  Sewell and ever competitive (Josh) Gibson. But, sadly not as competitive enough across the group as our opponents.

I guess when you have witnessed the club grow since 2005 to the level of membership and good health it enjoys today, you just expect it to keep performing at the highest level.

Hopefully that will continue to be the case and the season has just started, so to make judgments based on one game is inappropriate.

That said, the tribal nature of the game drives our emotions and yesterday, in my frustration, I wrongly singled out Alastair and for what was a team result for which we all must accept responsibility and be challenged to do better, week on week.

I sincerely apologise to Alastair Clarkson and his family for the grief I have caused them.

EARLIER today, Hawks captain Luke Hodge urged Kennett to think before he opens his mouth.

"Jeff done great things for our football club when he was president of the footy club," Hodge said on Tuesday morning.

"Now he is a frustrated person who is very opinionated. Some of the things (he says), I think he should think before he speaks ... a lot of smart people in football disagree with what he had to say.

"You have to take the good with the bad and I don't think you are going to change Jeff."

Speaking on Nova 100 on Tuesday morning, Hodge said Kennett was someone who "loves to get his opinion across because of who he is", but believed the club's most outspoken supporter needed to tone down criticism.

After watching his side lose to Geelong for the 10th consecutive time at the MCG on Sunday - to continue the 'Kennett Curse' -  the man himself said it was time for a change.

Asked if he thought Clarkson should be moved on at end of the season, Kennett said: "Yes."

"I think we need to introduce a freshness at the club that doesn't exist at the moment because so many of the personnel have been there for a number of years," Kennett told 3AW last night.

"They have been listening to the same voice for too long."

HAVE YOUR SAY - IS IT TIME FOR CLARKO TO GO?

Clarkson, who has a 57 per cent winning percentage in his eight years at the helm, has another year remaining on his contract.

But Kennett said last night the club had "underachieved" since winning the 2008 premiership.

"I always believe six to eight years is long enough any coach should stay at any club," he said

"He has brought great service to the club, but he has been in charge of one of the best groups of young men going around in footy now for a number of years now, certainly since 2008.

"There was an excuse in 2009 for our performance because of injury.

"But in 2010, 2011, 2012 we underperformed...someone has to accept responsibility for that."

Kennett said the club should look at appointing an untried assistant coach rather than try to lure a big name.

"I'd be looking for a second-tier coach who has proved himself and hungry for success and trying to prove himself," he said.

"I don't believe you look around for another senior coach - you elevate an assistant coach who has something to prove.

"Alastair has now been there for a long time, the players understand him very well...you have to freshen up the group.

"And we have a very good list still."

Kennett said near enough was not good enough at Hawthorn.

"What are we doing right? We're not winning flags," he said.
 


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Herald Sun Player of the Year

Jobe Watson has made a flying start to 2013. Picture: Michael Klein Source: Herald Sun

THE stars have come out to start the season, clogging the leaderboard in the Herald Sun Player of the Year Award.

Brownlow fancies Jobe Watson, Trent Cotchin, Joel Selwood and Scott Pendlebury all scored maxiumum votes for their performances in Round 1.

And Gary Ablett can consider himself unlucky three is the maximum number of votes available in any game after his incredible effort against St Kilda.

Joining the big names on three votes are Bulldogs ruckman Will Minson and Port Adelaide midfielder Hamish Hartlett.

Votes this year will be awarded on a 3-2-1 basis for the best three players on the field.

LEADERBOARD
3 Jobe Watson (Ess)
3 Michael Barlow (Frem)
3 Trent Cotchin (Rich)
3 Will Minson (WB)
3 Kieren Jack (Syd)
3 Gary Ablett (GC)

3 Hamish Hartlett (PA)
3 Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
3 Joel Selwood (Geel)

ROUND 1

ESSENDON v ADELAIDE
Reece Homfray's votes
3 Jobe Watson (Ess)
2 Ben Howlett (Ess)
1 Dyson Heppell (Ess)

FREMANTLE v WEST COAST
Braden Quartermaine's votes
3 Michael Barlow (Frem)
2 David Mundy (Frem)
1 Danyle Pearce (Frem)

RICHMOND v CARLTON
Warwick Green's votes
3 Trent Cotchin (Rich)
2 Brett Deledio (Rich)
1 Chris Judd (Carl)

W BULLDOGS V BRISBANE LIONS
Glenn McFarlane's votes
3 Will Minson (WB)
2 Nick Lower (WB)
1 Brett Goodes (WB)

GWS V SYDNEY
Neil Cordy's votes
3 Kieren Jack (Syd)
2 Ryan O'Keefe (Syd)
1 Adam Treloar (GWS)

GOLD COAST V ST KILDA
Greg Davis's votes
3 Gary Ablett (GC)
2 David Armitage (StK)
1 Jarrod Harbrow (GC)

MELBOURNE V PORT ADELAIDE
Bruce Matthew's votes
3 Hamish Hartlett (PA)
2 Travis Boak (PA)
1 Brad Ebert (PA)

NORTH MELBOURNE V COLLINGWOOD
Jon Ralph's votes
3 Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
2 Andrew Swallow (NM)
1 Dane Swan (Coll)

GEELONG v HAWTHORN
Bruce Matthews' votes
3. Joel Selwood (Geel)
2. Sam Mitchell (Haw)
1. Mathew Stokes (Geel)


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

SuperCoach: Trade or hold?

Adelaide's Patrick Dangerfield under extreme pressure against Essendon. Source: Getty Images

SHOULD we hit the trade button already on underperforming stars or to grab an early bargain? Al Paton weighs up the pros and cons.

We've all felt it - the itchy trigger finger.

Unless you're on top of the overall leaderboard, we've all got players in our SuperCoach teams who didn't live up to their potential in Round 1.

Meanwhile, other players we almost picked, or just never thought about, are racking up the points for everyone else's team.

The temptation to trade straight away is almost overwhelming. And with 30 trades this season, what's the harm?

Take a deep breath.

There are still 22 rounds to play, another week until player prices change and head-to-head matches begin, and two days until the first rolling lockout of Round 2.

There might be a good reason to make a trade, but make sure you've thought it through properly first. Here's some points to consider:

When a trade is a good idea

There are a couple of good reasons to get your team right before the private league season begins:

GETTING RID OF A PERMANENT DONUT

It's hard to know which young players will get a game before Round 1, and there's no shame in backing the wrong horse.

Watch the team selections this week and if one of your bench players is still yet to make an appearance, it's probably a good idea to trade them in for a rookie who is playing and about to increase in value (see list below).

LONG-TERM INJURY

Getting burnt by injury in Round 1 is not easy to take (yes, we're talking about you Mark LeCras). But there isn't much point hanging on to a player when he can't score points for more than two weeks. See the list below for possible alternatives - fellow Eagle Josh Kennedy seems the obvious swap for the Frenchman.

Eagle Mark LeCras comes off the ground with a serious arm injury. Picture: Daniel Wilkins Source: PerthNow

When trading is a bad idea

ONE BAD GAME

It's only natural to be dirty on Patrick Dangerfield for scoring just 63 in the opening round, or to be dirty on yourself for picking him instead of a player like Scott Pendlebury - who scored a lazy 160 - or David Mundy, who managed 126 despite costing $150,000 less than Dangerfield.

But we only have to look back to Round 1 last season to see how dangerous it can be to read too much into one game.

Magpie Steele Sidebottom managed just 72 points against Hawthorn in Round 1, 2012. If you jumped off him, you would have missed one of the year's best mid-price options as Sidebottom went on to average 106 for the season.

Eagle Andrew Gaff scored just 60 against the Bulldogs 12 months ago, then averaged 90 for the rest of the year. In the same match Dogs forward Tory Dickson scored just 30 points. He turned out to be an excellent forward bench choice, ending the year with an average of 70 points a game.

Conversely, the rookie everyone wanted to jump on this time last season was Bulldog Clay Smith, who scored 102 in his first match. Unfortunately, Smith didn't go close to matching that again, finishing the season with an average of 52.

Eagles forward Josh Kennedy scored 115 in that Bulldogs match (sound familiar?). If you jumped on him after that game you would have received all the benefits of a season average of 56 points a game - and, importantly, none of those 115 points count to your total no matter how quickly you hit the trade button.

That's not to say Round 1 means nothing. Last season Brad Ebert surprised with a score of 111 first-up, and he held that form all season.

But if a premium has bombed (Dangerfield) there is usually a reason behind it.

Back the choices you made after weeks - or months - of research over gut feel after one game.

Steele Sidebottom's Magpies are rolling in money, spending a massive $21.2 million on their football department alone last season. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: Herald Sun

MY RANKING NEEDS URGENT IMPROVEMENT

If you're feeling down about your start to the SuperCoach season, here's a stat that will make you feel better: last year's overall winner was ranked 67,429th after Round 1.

Michael Thuen went on to claim the $50,000 prize even though his team Chewylizard ranked in the top 1000 for the week just three times for the season.

As Mick Malthouse would say, it's a marathon, not a sprint.

I DON'T WANT TO MISS THE PRICE JUMP

Round 3 is vital for SuperCoach - it's when our head-to-head private league matches start, and also when player prices change for the first time. Prices go up and down every week after a player has played three matches, based on form.

That means next week is your last chance to grab a star rookie before he goes up in price, or to offload a dud before his price drops. The key to improving your team all season is to make money so it's vital you have players who increase in value.

It also means you have one more week to assess the form of players before making the decision to use a trade.

See the "one bad game" point above on why it's dangerous to make a move too soon.

But if you're still feeling trigger happy, keep an eye on these bargain selections this week. If they pull out another big score, it's worth making a switch to get them in your side:

Oliver Wines (Port Adelaide) $169,500 mid. Round 1 score: 125
Jack Viney (Melbourne) $109,500 mid. Round 1 score: 117
Brett Goodes (Western Bulldogs) $128,200 def/mid. Round 1 score: 113
Jasper Pittard (Port Adelaide) $128,000 def. Round 1 score: 93

And some mid-pricers who could be in for a hefty price rise:

Brent Moloney (Brisbane) $362,400 mid. Round 1 score: 100
Tom Liberatore (Western Bulldogs) $444,400 mid. Round 1 score: 130
Josh Kennedy (West Coast) $299,600 fwd. Round 1 score: 109
David Mundy (Fremantle) $477,300 mid. Round 1 score: 126
Danyle Pearce (Fremantle) $458,800. Round 1 score: 130
Ben Howlett (Essendon) $447,500. Round 1 score: 164

Port Adelaide midfielder Oliver Wines. Source: Getty Images


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

My family were 'bitter' with Pies

Mick Malthouse has no interest in making peace with Eddie McGuire.

Mick Malthouse and Eddie McGuire after the 2011 Grand Final loss to Geelong. Picture: Colleen Petch Source: Herald Sun

CARLTON coach Mick Malthouse has revealed his family were 'bitter' and 'disappointed with humanity' following his departure from Collingwood as the build up to Sunday's blockbuster at the MCG intensifies.

As he prepares to face his former club for the first time, Malthouse has made public his family's distaste of the coaching handover to Nathan Buckley following the 2011 grand final defeat.

"They (my family) thought it (coaching) was finished at the end of Collingwood," he said in the third and final instalment of his Malthouse: No Limits documentary.

"They were very disappointed, bitter in many respects, with the way it finished (at Collingwood).

"And really done with football and disappointed with humanity, if you like.

"I like to build things on friendship, and they go along with that friendship – when it's broken, it's broken and badly broken."

His wife, Nanette, also revealed she could not wait for Sunday's blockbuster at the MCG to be over.

Carlton coach Mick Malthouse and wife Nanette. Picture: Julie Kiriacoudis Source: Herald Sun

"I'm just dreading it," she said in the documentary.

"I'll just be glad for it to be over because it's all everybody talks about.

"I'd like to go and hide away somewhere."

The three-time premiership coach admitted he was expecting to cop some comments from over the fence on Sunday.

"I'm sure the media will make more out of it than what it should be...(but) if I draw the attention and it helps my team, so be it," he said.

"I am not silly enough to suspect that when we walk onto the ground at the MCG in Round 2 that there is not going to be some banter between the supporters and them to me."

Malthouse said most Collingwood supporters he had come across still held him in high regard.

"I haven't met one Collingwood supporter that has been negative," Malthouse said.

Dave Hughes and Peter Helliar tell us why they love to hate each other's footy teams.

"It surprised me because I don't think a lot of them know the full story.

"None the less, those that I do have contact with just acknowledge the fact I spent 12 good years at the Collingwood Football Club.

"Most wish me all the best, albeit with a follow up like, 'Why Carlton?'

The comments emerged the day after Malthouse made it clear he had no plans to reconcile with Magpies president Eddie McGuire.

"I have many things to do, but I don't think that is going to happen," Malthouse said on Fox Footy's On the Couch last night.

"And Eddie knows exactly the reasons why.

"I don't need to go there...there's a million things that happen on this planet and that are going to happen in football.

"I'm just focusing on this year."

McGuire has said he hoped to one day repair his relationship with Malthouse.


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Thomas cleared for Reid bump

Written By Unknown on Senin, 01 April 2013 | 16.18

North Melbourne goalsneak Lindsay Thomas faces a nervous wait with the match review panel after flooring Collingwood's Ben Reid with a big bump.

Lindsay Thomas clashed heads with Ben Reid. Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

NORTH Melbourne goalsneak Lindsay Thomas is in the clear for his off-the-ball bump that floored Magpie Ben Reid.

Thomas crashed into Reid with a fierce shepherd at Etihad Stadium, forcing the Magpie from the field with a bloody face as a result of a clash of heads.

The incident sparked a fierce war of words between opposing coaches after the match, with Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley labelling the hit an "average" act that would see the AFL "hold him to account for his actions".

Kangaroos coach Brad Scott defended his player, telling Buckley to "keep his opinions to himself".

VIDEO: See the incident in the video player above

But the match review panel today ruled the clash of heads was accidental and Thomas is free to play next weekend.

The panel ruled that despite making contact several metres off the ball, Thomas did not leave the ground and made contact to Reid's body with his shoulder and body.

The clash of heads which injured Reid was deemed to be "caused by circumstances outside the control of the player, which couldn't be reasonably foreseen."

The incident sparked a mini melee in the third quarter of the Etihad Stadium clash, with Reid bleeding from the mouth.

Live HQ: North Melbourne v Collingwood

The panel also cleared Carlton's Chris Yarran for a short jab to Richmond defender Bachar Houli, saying the contact wasn't sufficient to constitute a report.

Tom Scully, Jared Brennan and Kieren Jack are also in the clear after match-day reports for tripping, striking Stephen Milne and rough conduct were thrown out.

Melbourne's Colin Sylvia can accept a reprimand for striking Port Adelaide's Justin Westhoff at the MCG yesterday.

Brisbane defender Pearce Hanley can also accept a reprimand for an ugly spoil on Bulldogs veteran Daniel Giansiracusa.

If you don't mind, umpire: Round 1's most controversial calls

Social media was divided yesterday on whether Thomas would be rubbed out, but former Pies ruckman Josh Fraser leapt to the Roo's defence.

"Players block off the ball like Thomas did all the time. Not sure it's the crime people are making out," he tweeted.

The incident came among a stretch of Magpie goals as the undermanned side kicked four goals clear after the halftime break.

Brad Scott tells Buckley to "keep opinions to himself".


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Lyon questions Dees' courage

The AFL's contentious score review system has again come under fire with two incidents in today's Melbourne-Port Adelaide clash at the MCG

Nathan Jones after the match Picture: Harman Stephen Source: HWT Image Library

Melbourne great Garry Lyon with the players last season. Picture: George Salpigtidis Source: Herald Sun

MELBOURNE great Garry Lyon has launched a stinging attack on the Demons following their "demoralising" loss to Port Adelaide yesterday.

Lyon, who described the 79-point hammering as "heartbreaking", questioned the Demons' intensity, effort and courage.

"I've got absolutely no defence for the football club," Lyon said on Triple M today.

"Whatever comes their way they need to cop, and wear it and there is no defence at all that can be mounted for the performance that unfolded yesterday.

The Tackle: Demons simply pathetic

"The lack of pressure, the decision making, the lack of intestinal fortitude ... courage if you like. It was all there, anything you need to throw up was there to say (it was) absolutely hopeless.


"To come out for the first game of the year on your home ground, with credit to Port, they weren't playing Hawthorn or West Coast. This was a side that had six new players as well.
 

Live HQ: Melbourne v Port Adelaide

"You see guys going back with the flight and flinching and ducking their head and electing to punch rather than take possession, that to me, I don't ever excuse that in footy, but sometimes you can rationalise it, but not ever in a first game when your whole season is alive.

"It's demoralising to have a Round 1 like that ... I can cop floggings but I need to know what happens in the week following and I'm not confident in next week.

Lyon said coach Mark Neeld had to flog the players on the training track this week.

"Sacrifice an injury, sacrifice a tear ... if you don't compete out there, compete somewhere else."

Dees lay egg in Easter shock


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Selwood inspires Cats revival

Geelong captain Joel Selwood bursts out of trouble to set up a late goal for the Cats. Picture: Klein Michael Source: Herald Sun

CAPTAIN is a moniker that befits a warrior like Joel Selwood.

He oozes leadership, a fine trait that was never more evident than when the contest hung in the balance at the MCG.

Geelong's tardy first half required someone to show the way back against Hawthorn in the second half.

Selwood immediately and instinctively stepped forward in the critical third quarter which the Cats started with a 20 points deficit.

The midfielder simply willed himself to win the ball at a fiercely congested contest in the centre of the ground that set free Mitch Duncan to goal on the run.

Live HQ: SuperCoach scores and stats


Selwood built on that perfect start after the resumption by floating across a pack of players, with typical disregard for his own welfare, to mark and slot another goal.

And he hit a leading Tom Hawkins on the chest with a bullet pass a couple of minutes later for the big Cat to roost one from 50m to trail by only one point.

It was deflating for the Hawks to watch all their first half toil disintegrate in 10 minutes of sterling Selwood leadership that dragged along senior colleagues like Paul Chapman.

Just the same, it took Geelong until 15 minutes into the third quarter to grab the lead for the first time in what was another cracking contest between these rivals.

Geelong forward Allen Christensen kicked a critical last-quarter goal to set up the Cats victory over the Hawks. Picture:Michael Klein Source: Herald Sun


But you sensed the game was up for the dogged Hawks even when Shane Savage and Jarryd Roughead pulled back a couple of goals to snap the Cats' six-straight run late in the third term.

In the end, Geelong had too much run left and controlled the flow in the same manner as Hawthorn did in the first half.

When most players were sucking in deep breaths, Cats Travis Varcoe, Steven Motlop and Allen Christensen found acres of space to run and carry with devastating effect.

Goals by Christensen, James Podsiadly and Duncan pushed the Cats lead out to 21 points with only 10 minutes left.

And, while the brave Hawks kept coming with answers from Luke Breust and Savage, they were always going to run out of time as much as legs.

Tom Hawkins celebrates after kicking a goal during the 3rd quarter of the Hawthorn vs Geelong match at the MCG. April 1, 2013. Picture: Klein Michael Source: Herald Sun


Geelong's defence, so shaky in the first half, regained control, with Tom Lonergan containing Lance Franklin to just two goals.

And he had wonderful support from Harry Taylor, Andrew Mackie and Jared Rivers, particularly when the dangeous high balls floated within Buddy's reach.

Hawthorn should've gone into the long break with a bigger buffer than 20 points, particularly with 11 more inside 50 entries.

The Hawks dominated the first half, especially the centre clearances, with Sam Mitchell, Jordan Lewis and Brad Sewell right on top, and looked far more potent going forward.

Geelong's defenders were under immense pressure, illustrated by rare fumbles from the likes of Corey Enright and Mackie who have withstood the fierce heat of grand final battles.

When the Cats went forward, it was a scattergun approach.

They had been inside 50 11 times before Billy Smedts posted the first goal from a snapshot right against the boundary line.

Geelong increased the intensity in the second quarter, but the fumbles continued and a lack of system up forward presented key targets Hawkins and Podsiadly with few opportunities to operate one-out with opponents Josh Gibson and Ryan Schoenmakers.

At least the goals started to flow, especially with Podsiadly from a toepoke on the goalline and Hawkins two-steps snapshot from a mark close to the behind post.

And when the dangerous Varcoe crumbed a spilled ball at the top of the goal square for another with only seconds left on the clock, it set up an intriguing second half.

It may have taken the Cats 25 minutes to post their first goal and another half hour to find their touch, but the breathtaking manner they wrested the game away from the Hawks after half-time hammered out another warning of who was boss in these contests.

Sam Mitchell leads the hawks of the MCG after their 7 point loss to Geelong at the MCG. April 1, 2013. Picture: Klein Michael Source: Herald Sun


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Time for Clarkson to go: Kennett

Keep walking, Clarko. Former Hawk president Jeff Kennett says it is time for a change at Hawthorn. Source: Herald Sun

FORMER Hawthorn president Jeff Kennett has called for premiership coach Alastair Clarkson to be sacked at the season's end.

After watching his side lose to Geelong for the 10th consecutive time at the MCG today to continue the 'Kennett Curse',  the man himself said it was time for a change.

Asked if he thought Clarkson should be moved on at end of the season, Kennett said: "Yes."

"I think we need to introduce a freshness at the club that doesn't exist at the moment because so many of the personnel have been there for a number of years," Kennett told 3AW.

"They have been listening to the same voice for too long."

HAVE YOUR SAY - IS IT TIME FOR CLARKO TO GO?

Clarkson, who has a 57 per cent winning percentage in his eight years at the helm, has another year remaining on his contract.

But Kennett said the club had "underachieved" since winning the 2008 premiership.

"I always believe six to eight years is long enough any coach should stay at any club," he said

"He has brought great service to the club, but he has been in charge of one of the best groups of young men going around in footy now for a number of years now, certainly since 2008.

"There was an excuse in 2009 for our performance because of injury.

"But in 2010, 2011, 2012 we underperformed...someone has to accept responsibility for that."

Kennett said the club should look at appointing an untried assistant coach rather than try to lure a big name.

"I'd be looking for a second-tier coach who has proved himself and hungry for success and trying to prove himself," he said.

"I don't believe you look around for another senior coach - you elevate an assistant coach who has something to prove.

"Alastair has now been there for a long time, the players understand him very well...you have to freshen up the group.

"And we have a very good list still."

Kennett said near enough was not good enough at Hawthorn.

"What are we doing right? We're not winning flags," he said.
 


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Score review system sparks confusion

Written By Unknown on Minggu, 31 Maret 2013 | 16.18

The AFL's contentious score review system has again come under fire with two incidents in today's Melbourne-Port Adelaide clash at the MCG

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - MARCH 31: Jay Schulz of the Power takes a mark during the round one AFL match between the Melbourne Demons and Port Adelaide Power at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on March 31, 2013 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - MARCH 31: Jay Schulz of the Power takes a mark during the round one AFL match between the Melbourne Demons and Port Adelaide Power at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on March 31, 2013 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

THE AFL's contentious score review system created confusion at the MCG today when Jay Schulz was surprisingly paid a mark he seemed to take over the goal line.

The Power forward launched over a pack and cleanly reeled in a screamer on his chest, before the umpires called for a review and deemed the mark should stand.

VIDEO: See the incidents in the video player above

The ball was headed for a Port goal regardless, but later in the same quarter Melbourne mirrored the situation when recruit Cam Pedersen took a mark awkwardly close to the goal line.

LIVE HQ: SuperCoach scores, video, stats and more

The umpires then checked whether he completed it in play and if the ball hit the post, before awarding Pedersen a shot at goal, which he converted.

It followed a bizarre ruling in the Dogs-Lions clash yesterday, when Jack Redden appeared to dribble through a goal from the square only to have a behind given.

The umpires went upstairs for several minutes before ruling the ball was touched.

The league brought in the system just before the start of last season and it has suffered teething problems, with very few decisions able to be overturned due to a lack of conclusive vision.
 


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More

Lights out for Dees as Power surges

Melbourne leaves the field lead by Jack Grimes Picture: Harman Stephen Source: HWT Image Library

IT FELL to Angus Monfries to put the polish on Port Adelaide's training drill on a rare run at the MCG.

That the former Bomber was able to mark uncontested on the edge of the goal square midway through the third quarter told only a part of Melbourne's sorry story.

The build up to Monfries' second goal for his new club was the ridiculous ease the Power players were able to ferry the ball around the southern wing in a wave of white jumpers.


Score review causes confusion at the MCG

Always one loose on the overlap to inevitably land the ball in the new forward's lap for another embarrassing goal.

Little wonder the patient Melbourne faithful broke into sustained hooting at the sound of the three-quarter time siren.


Generally, that reaction is aimed at the umpires - this time there's no doubt it was directed at their dysfunctional team.

The deplorable Demons had managed to scrounge a solitary behind from that third quarter after they were still in contest, facing a gettable 27 points deficit heading into the second half.

Simply, Melbourne never looked a winning chance.

Port Adelaide celebrate in the rooms after the game Picture: Harman Stephen Source: HWT Image Library


From the moment Port Adelaide pair Travis Boak and Hamish Hartlett took hold of the midfield duels in the opening minutes, the result was inevitable.

Only mystery was having to wait for the final siren for the full extent of the scoreboard carnage.

Nothing inspired the Melbourne players.

Not the ball hunger of new boy Jack Viney, not the gutsy comeback of key forward Mitch Clark, not even the spectacular "hanger'' mark and goal by recruit Cam Pedersen just before half time.

Live HQ: SuperCoach score, stats and more

Pedersen's goal left the Demons trailing by only 20 points, for goodness sake, with still half a game to play.What was Melbourne's response?

To allow Port Adelaide to dictate every aspect of play to literally stroll to their 79 points victory, only 10 short of the Power's greatest winning margin against the once proud team of the red and the blue.

Remember, the Power also had half a dozen new players in their line-up for what was a dream start for coach Ken Hinkley.

But the astute Hinkley knows his team won't be able to similarly run the ball unchecked and mark uncontested this season ... probably starting with a home assignment against the young Giants next Saturday night.Obviously, it's far too early to accurately assess Hinkley's effect on Port Adelaide.

The signs were healthy first up, like the midfield unit led by skipper Boak and Monfries class adding a new dimension to a forward set-up built around the dangerous Jay Shulz.

The Power players were disciplined, accountable to their opponents and worked together with a structure and purpose that was missing in their opponents haphazard ball use.

Mitch Clarke gets helped off the ground Picture: Harman Stephen Source: HWT Image Library


An interchange bench infringement when onballer Jordie McKenzie prematurely returned to the field early in the third term summed up the Demons dismay day.

But it was the complete lack of any system in Melbourne's play that most distressed its fans that made up all but a small pocket of the disappointing 22,924 crowd.

Viney's impressive debut was the only highlight of the Demons' bleak Easter Sunday.It started with teenager's breakaway burst, one bounce and pinpoint pass to Colin Sylvia midway through the opening quarter.

And he finished with 22 possessions, bettered only by captain Jack Grimes.In retrospect, the warning signs were flashing early for the Demons.

A free kick to Grimes was Melbourne's first effective kick ... and the contest had been running nearly six minutes.


16.18 | 0 komentar | Read More
techieblogger.com Techie Blogger Techie Blogger